Paper trades only · Simulated, no real money, no orders · Not financial advice (TINFA)
Poutine Capitalpaper research lab
Live · run 21

Data as of 18 Nov 2026

Next update: after the next close or trigger check

rules v1.08 challengers

PAPER TRADES ONLY. All positions are simulated research positions. No real money is traded, no orders are placed, and nothing here is investment advice. This is not financial advice (TINFA).

Live research engine

The brain.

The lab’s lessons, forward evidence, and rules in test.

Every closed paper trade becomes a lesson. Lessons become hypotheses. A hypothesis only changes the lab's rules after it wins on trades it has never seen.

Lessons learned
78
Flags replayed
156
Challengers in test
8
Current rules
v1.0
Last update
78 lessons · 8 challengers

The brain, thinking

checking the gate

A replay of its last run. Not a live execution. Connections show the research process, not individual lesson attribution.

From lessons to forward evidenceNodes and scores come from the public research record. This animation replays its latest recorded state.LESSONSHYPOTHESESCHALLENGERSGATEStopped by noiseWhipsawedGave back a gainProfit rule would have helpedClean lossExit rulesStop rulesCombinedE-1 · +1.26 practiceE-2 · +1.20 practiceE-3 · +1.48 practiceE-4 · +0.06 practiceS-1 · −0.45 practiceS-2 · −1.22 practiceS-3 · −0.31 practiceC-1 · +0.99 practiceGate↗20 flags · 90%
From every closed trade and dead flag

What it has learned.

Stopped by noise · out almost as soon as it was in

29

Whipsawed · stopped, then back above the line the same day

24

Gave back a gain of 3% or more before the stop

10

A profit-taking rule under test would have closed it green

10

Clean loss · the stop did its job

5

What the brain believes right now

  • 29 of 44 stops came almost immediately after entry.
  • 10 trades were up 3% or more before giving it back.
  • 24 of 44 stops closed back above the line later the same day.
Shadow-tested on new flags

Challengers in test.

CH-v1.0Current rules · v1.0

The lab's original rules

Every challenger is scored against these rules on the same flags.

C-1Combo

Tests a profit target together with a calmer stop

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): +0.99 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

E-1Exit

Tests taking profit at a fixed gain

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): +1.26 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

E-2Exit

Tests taking profit at a larger fixed gain

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): +1.20 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

E-3Exit

Tests letting winners run further before taking profit

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): +1.48 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

E-4Exit

Tests protecting a gain once it appears

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): +0.06 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

S-1Stop

Tests giving the stop more room below the line

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): −0.45 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

S-2Stop

Tests judging the stop on the day's close instead of every 15 minutes

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): −1.22 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

S-3Stop

Tests requiring two closes below the line before stopping

Forward evidence0 / 20flags
Confidence it beats the current rules
Not posted

Practice score on past flags (not counted): −0.31 pts per flag vs current rules · hindsight

In test since 18 Nov 2026

Challengers and the current rules are both replayed on the same chart-feed bars, so their comparison is like-for-like; the book on the home page is the lab's own record.

Ruled out

Nothing has been ruled out yet. Rejected challengers will stay listed here.

The gate

How a rule change happens.

A challenger takes over only when all of these hold on forward trades: at least 20 flags traded by either version, at least 90% confidence it does better on the same flags, a positive average, and a drawdown no worse than the current rules' by more than a quarter. Then the version number moves up, the change is logged in Lab updates, and every earlier trade keeps the version it ran under.

Same rules, same bars

Integrity check.

Engine reproduced 39 of 45 lab trades exactly, 4 within one bar

Before trusting any challenger, the brain replays the lab's own rules on the same bars and checks it gets the same trades. Residual gaps come from the lab and the chart feed using different 15-minute data.

Forward scope only

Confidence history.

Forward evidence starts 18 Nov 2026. The chart fills in as new flags close.

Newest first

Brain log.

14 entries
  1. Engine reproduced 39 of 45 lab trades exactly, 4 within one bar

  2. Engine reproduced 34 of 45 lab trades exactly, 3 within one bar

  3. Registered S-3: Tests requiring two closes below the line before stopping · motivated by 28 'noise_stop' lessons

  4. The brain has now learned 75 lessons from closed paper trades and dead flags

  5. The brain has now learned 50 lessons from closed paper trades and dead flags

  6. The brain has now learned 25 lessons from closed paper trades and dead flags

  7. Engine reproduced 37 of 45 lab trades exactly

  8. Registered C-1: Tests a profit target together with a calmer stop · launch challenger

  9. Registered E-1: Tests taking profit at a fixed gain · launch challenger

  10. Registered E-2: Tests taking profit at a larger fixed gain · launch challenger

  11. Registered E-3: Tests letting winners run further before taking profit · launch challenger

  12. Registered E-4: Tests protecting a gain once it appears · launch challenger

  13. Registered S-1: Tests giving the stop more room below the line · launch challenger

  14. Registered S-2: Tests judging the stop on the day's close instead of every 15 minutes · launch challenger